Professional lifestyle photograph accompanying the KimonBids Journal article "What Commercial Director Means When You Bid for Public Contracts".

Bid writing

What Commercial Director Means When You Bid for Public Contracts

A practical SME guide to the Commercial Director role in public sector bids, covering bid decisions, pricing, cash flow, contract risk and compliance.

Michael Kitt, founder and public procurement analyst at KimonBidsMichael Kitt··7 min read

Key takeaways

  • The Commercial Director makes sure a bid is commercially sound, not just persuasive, testing whether you can win, deliver and earn an acceptable return.
  • A disciplined bid or no bid review protects your time and cash before you commit to writing a response.
  • Price the full cost of delivery, including mobilisation, risk allowance and the financing cost of slow payment terms.
  • Treat every promise in your quality response as a potential contractual obligation with an owner, a cost and a delivery method.
  • A compliance matrix and a single risk register keep evidence, obligations and pricing aligned before submission.

A Commercial Director is the person who makes sure a bid stacks up as a business decision, not just as a well written document. In a smaller organisation that person may be the managing director, the finance director, a sales lead or an external adviser. Whatever the job title, the responsibility is the same: turn a tender opportunity into a controlled decision. Can we win it, can we deliver it, and can we earn an acceptable return without taking on risk we cannot manage?

That question matters because public procurement rewards the most advantageous tender, not simply the cheapest one. Buyers assess bids against published criteria and a stated methodology, which can include quality, price, delivery risk and social value. The Commercial Director is the person who holds all of those threads together. For a concise definition you can share with colleagues, see the Commercial Director glossary entry.

What the role actually covers in a public sector bid

The Commercial Director role is far broader than sales. A sales lead concentrates on winning the opportunity. The Commercial Director has to test whether the contract is genuinely viable once it has been won. In practice the role owns or coordinates a long list of commercial tasks.

  • Bid or no bid decisions
  • Pricing and financial modelling
  • Contract risk review
  • Compliance with the tender instructions
  • Commercial assumptions and exclusions
  • Subcontractor and supply chain arrangements
  • Negotiation within the limits allowed by the procedure
  • Approval of the final offer
  • Handover from the bid team to delivery and finance

Think of this person as the final gate before a submission leaves the building. They are not there to polish prose. They are there to confirm that the organisation can keep every promise it has made, at the price it has quoted, under the contract it has accepted. That is why the role connects so closely with the work of the Bid Manager, who runs the process, and with finance, who confirm the numbers.

The market context reinforces why this discipline pays off. KimonBids live data for November 2026 recorded 1,253 live tenders published, last 30 days, which is far more than any SME could sensibly chase. A Commercial Director who filters opportunities ruthlessly frees the team to focus on the bids they can actually win and deliver. The same data snapshot recorded 718 pipeline notices published, last 30 days, which gives a commercial lead early sight of work before the contract notice appears, so planning can start before the clock begins.

Before bidding, decide whether the opportunity fits

The first question is never "Can we write a good response?" It is "Should we spend scarce resources on this at all?" A structured review prevents wasted effort and protects your bid budget. Work through these points honestly.

  • Is the requirement within our genuine capability?
  • Does the contract size fit our people, cash and management capacity?
  • Are the conditions of participation achievable?
  • Is the required insurance, certification or financial standing proportionate?
  • Can we accept the proposed payment terms?
  • Are there onerous liabilities, service credits or termination rights?
  • Can we evidence the required experience?
  • Is the timetable realistic?
  • Is the expected margin worth the delivery and compliance risk?

The Procurement Act 2023 requires contracting authorities to have regard to barriers faced by smaller suppliers and to consider whether those barriers can be removed or reduced, for example by dividing contracts into lots. That helps, but it does not remove your own duty to assess the opportunity commercially.

Worked example of a bid or no bid decision

Imagine an IT support firm weighing a three year council contract worth 240,000 pounds a year. Direct delivery is estimated at 175,000 pounds a year, leaving a potential gross contribution of around 65,000 pounds. The bid will cost roughly 12,000 pounds to produce. The specification demands round the clock support, which means recruiting two more engineers. The liability cap is twice the annual charge, so potential exposure reaches 480,000 pounds. Payment terms are 60 days, and there is a possible transfer of incumbent staff under TUPE.

The sensible conclusion here may well be to bid, but only on clear conditions. Confirm that recruitment can be delivered, model the cash flow impact, obtain the transfer information and secure board approval for the liability exposure. A formal go or no go decision records that reasoning so the team is not guessing later.

Reading the tender commercially

Tender documents scatter commercial information across many sections. The Commercial Director should pull it into a single risk and obligations register, so nothing important hides in an annex. Build a register that covers the whole bargain, not just the headline service.

  • Specification and service levels
  • Pricing schedule
  • Award criteria and weightings
  • Conditions of participation
  • Draft contract
  • Key performance indicators
  • Data protection and information security requirements
  • Social value commitments
  • Mobilisation timetable
  • Change control provisions
  • Liability, indemnity and insurance provisions
  • Termination and exit assistance

Do not assume a promise in the quality response is harmless. If the bid says you will provide named staff, monthly reports, fixed response times or extra training, those statements can become contractual obligations. A useful rule is that every promise in the tender response should have an owner, a cost, a delivery method and a place in the contract risk review. Reading the published award criteria carefully tells you where quality and price sit in the balance, which in turn shapes how boldly you can commit.

Building a price that can survive delivery

A public sector price should reflect the full cost of performing the contract, not just wages or materials. A workable model adds direct costs, allocated overhead, a risk allowance and profit. For a recurring service you also need to model mobilisation, recruitment and training, equipment, management time, travel, subcontractor margins, inflation, financing costs caused by slow payment, contract management effort and any exit obligations.

Worked pricing example

Consider a facilities maintenance firm estimating annual costs of 180,000 pounds for engineers, 45,000 pounds for materials, 20,000 pounds for vehicles and travel, 18,000 pounds for contract management, 22,000 pounds for allocated overhead and 15,000 pounds as a risk allowance. That totals 300,000 pounds. If the firm needs an operating profit of 45,000 pounds, the tender price should be 345,000 pounds before VAT and any pricing rules in the tender.

Suppose the tender awards 60 percent for quality and 40 percent for price. Cutting the price may lift the price score but could weaken delivery. Test at least three scenarios.

  • Base case with expected staffing, costs and margin
  • Downside case with higher absence, inflation or subcontractor costs
  • Upside case with efficiency savings you can evidence and actually deliver

The cheapest price is not automatically the best commercial decision, and a building a reusable bid content library speeds up the modelling next time. Buyers must evaluate fairly against the published criteria, so your score depends on more than price alone.

Checking affordability and reviewing contract risk

Profit does not guarantee cash. You can win a profitable contract and still struggle if you pay staff and suppliers long before the buyer pays you. If monthly delivery costs 25,000 pounds, payment takes 60 days and mobilisation costs 40,000 pounds in month one, you may need to fund roughly 90,000 pounds before receipts stabilise. Confirm the following before you commit.

  • Available cash and overdraft facilities
  • Whether mobilisation can be invoiced
  • Payment milestones and any retention provisions
  • Supplier payment terms
  • Whether a parent company guarantee or performance bond is required
  • The effect of delayed acceptance or disputed invoices

Public sector contracts are often drafted by the buyer and may allow limited negotiation. Classify each important term as acceptable, acceptable with a priced assumption, requiring clarification, requiring board or insurer approval, or a reason not to bid. Pay close attention to unlimited liability, broad indemnities, service credits that exceed your likely margin, long fixed prices, one sided termination rights, intellectual property ownership and mandatory systems or staff. A clarification question should name the precise issue and explain its financial effect, not advertise a weakness. For example, ask whether a liability cap applies in aggregate across the term or separately to each claim, and whether it is meant to include service credits.

Finally, keep your evidence current. Maintain a compliance matrix listing each requirement, its response location, the evidence, the owner and the status. The central digital platform for the Procurement Act 2023 regime uses an enhanced Find a Tender service with a single registration point for suppliers, so keep your capability statement and certificates ready rather than assembling them the night before the deadline.

Frequently asked questions

Does an SME need a dedicated Commercial Director to bid for public contracts?

No. The function matters more than the job title. In many small firms the managing director or finance director performs the Commercial Director role, confirming that the bid is affordable, deliverable and commercially sound before submission. What matters is that someone owns the pricing, the contract risk review and the final approval.

How is the Commercial Director different from the Bid Manager?

The Bid Manager runs the process, coordinates contributors and makes sure the response is complete and compliant on time. The Commercial Director tests whether the opportunity makes business sense, owns the pricing and risk decisions, and approves the final offer. On a small bid one person may do both, but the two responsibilities are distinct.

Why does cash flow matter so much in public sector bidding?

Because a profitable contract can still cause difficulty if you pay staff and suppliers well before the buyer pays you. Mobilisation costs, retention provisions and payment terms of 60 days can create a significant funding gap. The Commercial Director should model the cash requirement and confirm facilities are in place before committing.

Can promises in the quality response become contractual obligations?

Yes. Commitments such as named staff, response times, reporting frequency and social value activity can be written into the contract. Treat every promise as something with an owner, a cost and a delivery method, and make sure it appears in your contract risk review so you are not caught out after award.

A smiling team ready to bid on government contracts

Win more government contracts

Start finding, scoring, and drafting bids for UK public sector work today.

No credit card required. Free plan available.

What Commercial Director Means When You Bid for Public Contracts | KimonBids